E-mail: tina@yuzechemical.com

Contact Us

Contact: Tina Pan
Email: tina@yuzechemical.com
Wechat: +8618660611992
Whatsapp: +8618660611992
Address: Xinxing Village, Dajiawa Street, Binhai Economic Development Zone,Weifang City ,Shandong Province,China.
Website: www.wfyuzehg.com

News

Which Deicer Does the Least Damage? Yuzhe CMA Manufacturer Tells You(Corrosion Ranking, Metal Compatibility and Snow-Melting Temperature Curves)

Conclusion Corrosion ranking (from strongest to weakest corrosion on steel and aluminum parts of vehicle chassis): Sodium chloride ice melter (rock salt) > calcium chloride ice melter > regular magnesium chloride ice melter > blended ice melter (formulated with magnesium chloride, calcium chloride and sodium chloride in certain ratios) > inhibited magnesium chloride ice melter (or blended ice melter added with corrosion inhibitor) > calcium magnesium acetate (CMA)

With increasingly stringent global environmental regulations, two core indicators are prioritized for deicing material selection on urban roads, bridges, parking lots and airport projects: metal compatibility with vehicle chassis, steel rebar, galvanized steel and aluminum alloy (the degree of side effects), and ice-melting performance curves at different temperatures.

1. Calcium Magnesium Acetate (CMA) (Top Recommended, Chloride-Free)

· Its corrosion rate on carbon steel is only around 1/10 of sodium chloride. It contains no chloride ions and prevents chloride-triggered electrochemical corrosion. It is gentle on chassis, aluminum alloy wheels and car paint, and biodegradable.

· Good low-temperature performance, effective at approximately -15℃ to -20℃.

· Drawback: Very high price.

· Widely applied at airports, scenic spots, high-end parks, bridges, premium residential communities, developed regions and factories that manufacture precision instruments.

2.Chloride-Based Ice Melters (For regions with less strict requirements)

3.Sodium chloride ice melter (rock salt): Highly corrosive and low-cost.

4.Calcium chloride ice melter: Strong hygroscopicity and fast ice melting speed, yet still highly corrosive. It tends to form a persistent wet salt film sticking to the chassis and causes continuous corrosion.

5.Magnesium chloride ice melter:

✅ Compared with sodium chloride and calcium chloride, it features lower corrosion and excellent low-temperature performance (effective from -10℃ to -15℃). Corrosion can be further reduced by adding professional corrosion inhibitors.

❌ Drawback: It still contains chloride ions. As a chloride product, repeated long-term contact will eventually lead to chassis rust, just at a slower rate. It is highly hygroscopic and leaves a long-lasting wet salt film on vehicle chassis after ice melts.

calcium magnesium acetate.png

Explanation of Ice-Melting Temperature Curves (Eutectic Temperature & Practical Working Temperature)

Two key terms to distinguish:

1. Eutectic temperature (theoretical minimum freezing point): The lowest temperature at which the brine solution can remain unfrozen.

2. Practical working temperature (on-site usable temperature): The temperature range for stable ice melting and breaking in field engineering. It is much higher than the eutectic temperature and serves as the main basis for procurement and selection.

Ice Melter Type

Eutectic Temperature

Recommended Practical Working Range

Features of Melting Curve

Hexahydrate magnesium chloride ice melter

-10℃ ~ -18℃

0℃ ~ -15℃

Fast melting above -10℃; actively absorbs moisture to form brine. Melting efficiency drops rapidly below -20℃ with a gentle downward curve.

Calcium magnesium acetate (CMA)

-15℃ ~ -25℃

0℃ ~ -35℃

Stable performance above -5℃; melting capacity drops sharply below -40℃. CMA is not designed for rapid ice dissolution. It mainly reduces adhesion between ice and pavement, provides anti-slip effect and loosens ice mass. It suits pre-spreading (anti-icing pretreatment) instead of emergency deicing under extreme cold.

Sodium chloride rock salt ice melter

-13℃

0℃ ~ -7℃

Performance declines rapidly at low temperatures and is nearly ineffective below -7℃.

1.Temperature curve of magnesium chloride ice melter Magnesium chloride ice melter is a hygroscopic chloride ice melter with a wide low-temperature working window. It delivers high melting efficiency from 0℃ to -10℃ and maintains decent ice-melting capacity between -10℃ and -20℃. Its efficiency decreases obviously close to -25℃. It can absorb moisture even on dry snow surfaces to form brine, so it is widely adopted by municipal departments and mining roads in cold North American regions. The downside is electrochemical corrosion on metals caused by chloride ions, so corrosion inhibitors are required to mitigate damage.

2.Temperature curve of calcium magnesium acetate (CMA) CMA performs well under moderate cold conditions. It offers stable snow melting and anti-icing performance from 0℃ down to -25℃, with low harm to metals and vegetation. Its ice-melting capacity falls quickly once pavement temperature stays below -40℃, so it is not suitable for emergency snow removal in extremely frigid zones. Different from chloride ice melters, its working principle is not to dissolve large volumes of ice rapidly. Instead, it breaks the bonding force between ice crystals and pavement, making snow easier to clear by snow plows. It is ideal for long-term preventive spreading on bridges, landscape roads and parking lots.

magnesium chloride ice melter.png

Notes:

· Even among magnesium chloride ice melters, acid-process white flakes and ordinary brine flakes vary in impurity content. Brine flakes with higher impurities show worse corrosion resistance.

· Some CMA cannot be mixed with strongly acidic materials. Yuze Chemical’s calcium magnesium acetate can be blended with many other products and has good anti-caking property.

· Magnesium chloride should avoid long-term sealed contact with magnesium alloy.

· Spreading tip: Pre-spreading in small, frequent doses causes less damage to metals and pavement than one-time heavy spreading after heavy snowstorms.



Home | Magnesium Chloride | Calcium Magnesium Acetate | News | About Us | Leave Message | Contact Us | Mobile XML
Copyright © Weifang Yuze Chemical Co.,Ltd